Senate Blocks California’s Gasoline Vehicle Ban

News Summary

In a recent Senate vote, California’s ambitions to ban gasoline-powered vehicles by 2035 were halted as lawmakers voted 51-44 to block the state’s regulatory measures. This decision is a rollback of the EPA waiver that allowed California to enforce stricter emissions standards. Governor Gavin Newsom criticized the action, highlighting potential setbacks for innovation and public health benefits. The decision raises questions about state authority and environmental regulations amidst warnings of adverse effects on air quality and electric vehicle sales.

California, home to the world’s fifth-largest economy, is set to face significant changes in its environmental regulations following a recent vote in the US Senate. Senators approved a measure by a vote of 51-44, blocking California’s program aimed at banning gasoline-powered cars and other vehicles by 2035. This action now heads to President Donald Trump, who is expected to sign the resolution into law, thus ending California’s ambitious goals for transitioning toward electric vehicles.

The Senate’s decision marks a rollback of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) waiver granted under former President Joe Biden. This waiver had permitted California to adopt stricter emissions standards than those set at the federal level, which have been in place for over 50 years. California’s originale plans were to ban new gasoline-only vehicle sales as part of its broader effort to combat climate change by significantly increasing the sale of electric and zero-emission vehicles.

Governor Gavin Newsom condemned the Senate’s decision, labeling it a detrimental move that risks pushing the U.S. further behind in global vehicle technology innovation while benefiting foreign competitors like China. The vote was surprisingly supported by only one Democrat, Senator Elissa Slotkin of Michigan, who sided with Republicans to throw out the California policy. The rejection of this measure is expected to hinder the state’s initiative to accelerate electric vehicle sales and may have repercussions for at least 11 other states intending to follow California’s lead. Collectively, these states account for approximately 40% of the U.S. auto market.

As a measure of California’s commitment to electric vehicles, regulations under the proposed Advanced Clean Cars II rule stipulated that by next year, 35% of new vehicles sold at California dealerships must be either zero-emission or plug-in hybrids. This would have gradually led to a complete ban on the sale of new gasoline-only vehicles by 2035. The repeal could have negative implications for public health, losing projected benefits estimated at $13 billion from reduced air pollution, which included the prevention of about 1,200 premature deaths related to poor air quality.

In 2023 and 2024, California’s commitment to zero-emission vehicle sales represented approximately 25% of all new car sales within the state. However, Republican senators argued that such stringent regulations could threaten the American auto industry by limiting consumer choice and burdening the national energy grid. The vote against California’s regulations could set a concerning precedent for future congressional actions targeting state regulations on environmental standards.

Alongside the repeal of California’s gasoline vehicle ban, the Senate also approved four additional resolutions aimed at blocking the state’s clean-air regulations for heavy-duty vehicles. This brings forth concerns regarding state authority and environmental protections that the Democratic senators have warned are at risk due to these new legislative actions.

California intends to challenge the congressional decision legally, asserting that it undermines its authority to implement stringent emissions rules. The state, having sought legal waivers from the EPA over 100 times, views this legislative use of the Congressional Review Act as a potential overreach of power. Democratic lawmakers have suggested that such actions are indicative of a broader trend aimed at eroding state rights and diminishing public health defenses against pollution.

The ongoing legal battle promises to be complex, as it will likely test the boundaries of state versus federal regulatory powers in environmental matters. Many observers are keenly watching how this situation unfolds, particularly in terms of its impact on the future of vehicle emissions standards in California and across the nation.

Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic

• The New York Times
• Wikipedia: Electric Vehicle
• Los Angeles Times
• Google Search: California gas only car ban
• Associated Press
• Google Scholar: California vehicle emissions regulations
• Bloomberg News
• Encyclopedia Britannica: Environmental Protection Agency
• The Center Square
• Google News: California gasoline vehicle ban